You are currently browsing the monthly archive for October 2010.

Two stories came to my attention this week, related in a sad way, one true, the other maybe not.

For the past two years, in northern Vermont up near the Canadian border, there had been reports of an albino moose – a rarity, made even more rare by the fact that it had apparently survived into adulthood. And for the past several years, in the West Country of Britain, there were stories of a red stag so large and so magnificent that it was nicknamed ‘The Emperor’ and generally thought to be Britain’s largest would animal.

Both were reported shot and killed by hunters – legally.

In Vermont, it was moose-hunting season. The 744-pound albino moose with an antler spread of 45 inches was brought to a weighing station. The hunter was a teenage girl who was hunting with her father. All very legal. There are no restrictions to shooting an albino moose in Vermont.

Things are a little sketchier in England. The original story of the killing of ‘The Emperor’ touched off a wave of national hand-wringing. The problem is, there’s no proof that the animal is actually dead, shot or otherwise. Reporters trying to get information are running into dead ends. People supposedly heard shots, and haven’t seen the stag in any of its regular places since.

Some have even begun to doubt that the animal ever existed, on a par with the Loch Ness monster.

True or not, both stories pose an ethical question. Are there circumstances when a hunter should back away from killing a particular animal even though it would be legal to do so? Or do we have to burden wildlife officials with the task of coming up with regulations for every possible special circumstance?

Advertisements

For those of you who may not have heard of it, October 27 has been designated as Climate Fools Day. It was created two or three years ago in the UK by a group of people politely referred to as “Climate Change Skeptics” – mostly energy industry hacks and assorted quacks.

The day is meant to mark the passage of a climate change bill by Parliament. It’s an expensive and controversial law, aimed at addressing the problem of climate change through a variety of green initiatives.

It may not be a perfect piece of legislation, but at last it’s something, which is more than can be said for the US Congress and other major countries.

Debating the pros and cons of any environmental legislation is healthy. There has to be discussion about what course of action to take. We need to reach a consensus if anything is going to work. But continuing to deny that the problem exists is madness, and a dangerous madness at that.

It’s akin to saying we shouldn’t refer to the planet as a globe because some people still think the earth is flat.

The Upper Blackstone Water Pollution Abatement District, ostensibly a body appointed to reduce pollutants getting into the Blackstone River, has decided to take the federal Environmental Protection Agency to court for being required to reduce the level of pollutants going into the Blackstone River.

It gets weirder.

When this was announced, it received the whole-hearted support of the Worcester City Council, including one city councilor who seemed to imply it was un-American to try to clean up the river.

“The EPA has shown how out of touch it is with America,” declared Councilor Joffrey Smith, as quoted in the Worcester Telegram and Gazette.It gets weirder still.

Pollution of the Blackstone River dates back to the beginnings of the Industrial Revolution. Over the past two decades, at least, the impact of these decades of pollution has been documented, and one of the major sources is the area around Worcester. Currently, the EPA’s concern is the level of phosphorus, which is causing rampant plant growth downstream and in Narragansett Bay, disrupting the ecosystm there. So, the EPA has set some limits to the amount that can be discharged from a wastewater treatment plant in nearby Millbury, to be phased in over a period of time.

All the scientific evidence to support this doesn’t faze the city’s public works commissioner, Robert Moylan, Jr., who called the limits “without scientific basis and will not result in meaningful benefits.”

He didn’t happen to mention how he knows it. He might have gotten this from his Ouija Board for all we know.

Their concern is what they consider the exorbitant cost of upgrading the plant to meet the new standards. This, they claim will put a terrible burden on the city’s ratepayers. Seems fair enough.

However, the fact is that city residents have been paying next to nothing up to now in sewer use fees. According to one study, the average household might see an annual cost of $100 to upgrade the plant. That’s $2 per week.

If any of these people are like me, they have cellphone service and app costs, internet service costs, cable television fees. All of which are significantly more expensive.

Now their city council and this mysterious board are going to file suit in the 1st Circuit Court of Appeals. How much will this cost the taxpayers of the city? As taxpayers, they’ll be paying the costs for both sides as well as court costs – since the EPA is funded with federal tax dollars, and the board by local tax dollars.

Is this ridiculous, or what?

In searching for an explanation as to how massive amounts of radioactive tritium could turn up in monitoring wells at Vermont Yankee last January, the NRC has decided to step in to the Wayback Machine, blaming shoddy construction and bad housekeeping back when the plant first opened in the 1970s.

I’m sure it’s strictly a matter of coincidence that the current owner, Entergy Corp. of New Orleans, is trying to get a license renewal. The NRC has to this point demonstrated that they’re pretty much in the company’s back pocket, praising the company’s handling – or mishandling – of a host of problems throughout this year.

And once again, the NRC report is just a re-wording of a report handed to them by Entergy.

The document, “The Root Cause Evaluation Report” raises some interesting questions. If these problems date back to the dawn of nuclear power in Vermont, how come no one picked up on it earlier? And if the plant has so many fundamental flaws, doesn’t it make sense just to shut it down, rather than keep on running it?

If this report as intended as just another NRC whitewash, it seems they may have shot themselves in the foot.

The news this week that zebra mussels have been found in two more lakes in Connecticut is yet another example how we often seem to be working at cross purposes when it comes to controlling invasive species.

Native to Russia and Eastern Europe, these freshwater clams made it to the Great Lakes in the 1980s via container ships.

With all the global trade, this was probably inevitable. They quickly spread eastward, reaching the Hudson River Basin, and have spread even further.

While there is a certain amount of natural migration, that would not explain their rapid spread. That comes from boaters. The mussels hitch a ride from one body of water to another. As a result, wherever they appear, wildlife officials have mounted publicity campaigns to urge boaters to thoroughly clean their boats before leaving an infested lake.

A single female can produce between 30,000 and 1 million eggs per year. There’s no known way to get rid of them. All anyone can do is to try to contain the spread.

The presence of these mussels can alter the food chain of a body of water, by filtering out the plankton, depriving much of the other aquatic life of a major food source. And as they multiply, they clog drains and other piping.

Unfortunately, too many don’t care or don’t understand the problem, and so the spreading continues.

Just a month after keeping Bill McKibben and a group of environmentalists at arm’s length when they tried to convince the president to put solar panels on the White House, Energy Secretary Steven Chu yesterday announced that solar panels will be installed at presidential residence next year.

It’s clearly an effort to try to put some minimal substance to the lip service this administration has been giving to environmental concerns.

It’s a small step, to be sure, but at least it provides some useful symbolism. There’s some comparison with the vegetable garden Michelle Obama had planted at the White House. It was a nice thing to do, an opportunity for some good photo-ops with cute schoolchildren. I wonder how often she went out there for some weeding?

I’m a little bothered by the unnecessary snub of Bill McKibben and his group. It’s not as if he showed up at the White House unannounced asking for an appointment. The whole thing had been planned and announced ahead of time.

What is the administration trying to say here? On the one hand, energy-efficiency and alternative energy are good things, but it’s not good to be seen associating with environmentalists? What was he afraid of?

The NRC’s merry band of pranksters have been working overtime approving one nuclear enrichment plant after another. This past week, they announced that the new Areva plant in Idaho has passed a safety review, moving that project right along.

Areva is a French company with a long history of shoddy work and safety problems all over the world. Just the other day, government inspectors in Finland were refused entrance to the work site where an Areva nuclear plant is under construction.

There have been numerous complaints of labor and safety violations at the site.

That particular project is also running well behind schedule, and running up a huge cost overrun. Is anyone surprised?

At about the same time that the NRC was helping out their friends at Areva, geologists announced that an active earthquake fault runs a few miles away from where the plant will be located. In fact, Idaho is criss-crossed with earthquake faults.

I wonder if anyone told the NRC … not that it would make any difference.

They go by the name Nuclear Regulatory Commission, but it might as well be called the Nuclear Industry’s office of rubber stamping. Basically, they’ve done nothing to ensure that the public will be safe from the hazards inherent in the operation of nuclear power plants.

The Union of Concerned Scientists last week issued a report finding that dozens of safety violations at the nation’s nuclear power plants have been routinely ignored by the NRC. The bad news is that prior to 2006 NRC enforcement of safety regulations is called “spotty,” but since then it’s become nonexistent. Despite more than two dozen known safety violations, not a single fine or sanction has been levied by the agency.

There are arguments for nuclear power as a source of energy, but not unless the two major issues of safe operation and spent fuel disposal can be solved.

The findings of the UCS have disturbing echoes of the problems surrounding the Gulf oil spill. The long-term environmental and economic effects of that disaster are still being evaluated. A major nuclear disaster would make the oil spill pale in comparison. A quarter of a century after the fact, animals in Germany and other parts of Europe are still showing up with high levels of radioactivity, the result of eating food still contaminated by the Chernobyl disaster in Russia.

Nature Blog Network

Categories

RSS The Ecocryptic

  • Maine DEP update July 31, 2013
    Maine Department of Environmental Protection has reversed itself and will schedule a public hearing on proposed changes to the state's clean air standards. No date has been set.Environmental groups, legislators, and the general public were outraged when the Portland Press Herald reported yesterday that the state agency had tried to sneak through the cha […]
  • At Maine’s DEP, it’s the fox guarding the henhouse July 30, 2013
    What happens when you put an industry lobbyist in charge of environmental protection? Just take a look at what’s going on in Maine. According to an article in today’s Portland Press-Herald, the state’s Department of Environmental Protection wants to weaken the state’s clean-air regulations, and they don’t want anyone to know about it.No public hearings have […]
  • Northern Pass Rears Its Ugly Head (Again) July 15, 2013
    Despite massive public opposition, significantly over-budget, and three years behind schedule,  the CEO of the Northern Pass Project vows the controversial high voltage transmission line will be built.The project is a 180-mile power line that would bring power from Canada to New England. It first came to the attention of environmentalists and others when the […]
  • Stung by Criticism, Utilities Go on Tree-Cutting Rampage August 11, 2012
    Here in the northeast, we’ve been hit by a succession of “weather events” – ice storms, wind-storms, hurricanes, early snowfall, late snowfall. Each one offered the utility companies serving this area to demonstrate once again that they were completely unprepared. In each case, customers in the most advanced country in the world were left without power for w […]
  • Victory for the Blackstone: Court backs EPA, Worcester must stop dumping sewage into river August 7, 2012
    Score one for the Blackstone River, and all the people who care about it. The U.S. First Circuit Court of Appeals has lifted a stay of enforcement of an EPA order that will force upgrades at the Upper Blackstone Water Pollution Abatement district sewage treatment plant, according to an article in the Worcester Telegram & Gazette.The problem is a simple o […]
  • NH Senate Denies Eminent Domain for Northern Pass – Or Does It? January 30, 2012
    Under intense public scrutiny, the New Hampshire Senate last week approved a bill that supposedly sets limits on the use of eminent domain to seize property for public projects and excludes using it for privately-funded projects. That would seem to exclude the controversial Northern Pass project, a proposed 180-mile transmission line that would bring hydroel […]
  • Northern Pass Developers Pushing State To Take Land By Force January 24, 2012
    Ever since the controversy began over the construction of a new transmission line to bring power from Canada into New Hampshire slicing through some of that state’s most scenic landscape, the backers of the project have been quietly lobbying for eminent domain powers to force reluctant landowners along the proposed route to sell.The issue gets its first real […]
  • The Balsams Landscape Has Been Saved! January 15, 2012
    Every once in a while the good guys win one.The Society for the Preservation of New Hampshire Forests has reached its goal of raising $850,000 to buy a 5,800-acre parcel of land near the famous Balsams Grand Hotel in Dixville Notch, NH. They made the announcement in a statement yesterday on their website.The land was considered a key piece on the proposed ro […]
  • Worcester officials cite city parks to defend continued pollution of Blackstone River December 29, 2011
    I was trying to find a short, pithy way of describing the gist of an article that appeared in today’s Worcester (Mass.) Telegram & Gazette.Here’s the story.The Blackstone River has its source in Worcester and flows through Rhode Island into Narragansett Bay. Since colonial times, residents and businesses have regarded it as their personal sewage system. […]
  • Slick media campaign hides the dark side of Northern Pass October 23, 2011
    The campaign to approve the billion-dollar plan to bring hydroelectric power from Canada to New England is in full swing. The home page for the project features pictures of all the things we like about New Hampshire, things like pristine lakes and woods. What it doesn’t show are the 140 miles of transmission lines criss-crossing the White Mountains, with 135 […]

RSS Martin Laine – Digital Journal

  • Giant tortoise species brought back from brink of extinction
    A species of Galapagos giant tortoises that numbered just 15 individuals 50 years ago, now has a healthy breeding population numbering over a thousand. The news is a rare bright spot at a time when the outlook for many species is increasingly bleak.
  • Stockholm’s backseat therapists to help battle ‘winter blues’
    As the months of extended darkness loom in the northern latitudes, so does the lethargy and depression known as “winter blues.” One Stockholm taxicab company is offering to have a therapist talk with their passengers during their ride.
  • New home colon cancer test goes on the market today
    Beginning today, a new home test for colorectal cancer will be available by prescription. The hope is that the millions of Americans who have been avoiding the unpleasant alternative testing methods will take advantage of it.
  • Heart transplant breakthrough could make more hearts available
    Surgeons in Australia have successfully transplanted hearts that had stopped beating, a major breakthrough in the process that had usually used only beating hearts. This could significantly increase the number of hearts available for transplantation.
  • Denmark rolls out the welcome mat for returning Jihadists
    While officials in many western countries are wringing their hands over what to do about those citizens who want to return after fighting with one of the extremist groups in Syria and Iraq, Denmark welcomes its returning Jihadists with open arms.
  • 'Let me survive this' says fugitive cop-killer lookalike
    Pity James Tully who has the misfortune of resembling Eric Frein, the object of a massive manhunt following the ambush shooting of two police officers six weeks ago, and who lives in Canadensis, Pa., the epicenter of the search.
  • Nine in Conn. ordered quarantined, monitored for Ebola
    Nine people, including a family of six, have been ordered to stay in their homes for the next three weeks while public health officials check for signs that they have contracted the Ebola virus. None of them have shown any signs of the illness so far.
  • Mass. stool bank offers donors $40 a poop
    Ever since the discovery that healthy human stool bacteria could be used to cure such debilitating diseases as colitis, the medical profession has struggled with two problems — collecting a sufficient supply and finding a way to get it into a patient.
  • Chinese officials scramble to find Putin’s tiger before poachers
    Kuzya, a 23-month-old orphaned Siberian tiger that Russian President Vladimir Putin helped release back into the wild in May, has crossed into China. The last thing Chinese officials want is for Kuzya to fall victim to poachers.
  • Trial raises questions over Navy's order for silencers
    What started out as an investigation into an alleged contract fraud scheme by a U.S. Navy directorate involving untraceable rifle silencers has raised questions about whether they were part of a secret mission or rogue operation.